BibleThought
  • Home
    • Hospital Patients/Caregivers >
      • Blessed by an Angel
      • No Visitors Please
      • Side Effects of Chemo
      • Need Help Coping?
      • Cancer and Genetics
    • Site Guide
    • Quora.com Questions
    • 3 Minute Videos
  • Understanding
    • Why I Believe the Bible >
      • Evidence for the Resurrection
      • Arguments Against Evolution
      • Atheism
      • Jesus in History
    • Can We Understand the Bible? >
      • Alleged Contradictions >
        • Is Jesus God?
        • Justified by Works or Not?
        • Predestination or Free Will?
        • Bible Verse Comparisons
      • Difference: Old and New Testaments
      • Bible Complexity
      • Why Are There Difficult Passages?
      • Causes of Common Errors >
        • The Bible's Second Purpose
        • Why Many Will Not Obey?
        • Hasty Generalizations
        • Language of Ashdod
        • Insertion of the "Only" Word
        • Making Rules from Exceptions
    • Is the Bible Sufficient?
    • Translations and Versions
    • Silence of the Scriptures
    • Bible Study Principles >
      • Systematic Bible Study
      • Study the Bible for Yourself
      • The Milk and the Meat
      • Consider the Context
      • Comprehensive Study Techniques
      • Biblical Rules for Study
      • Teaching Aids >
        • Bible Study Questions
        • Teacher's Guide to Questions
        • Periods of Bible History
    • Determining Bible Authority >
      • God's Laws Within Relationships
      • Biblical Commands
      • Biblical Examples
      • Biblical Implications
      • Generic and Specific Commands
      • Example of Conflict Resolution - Acts 15
      • Strictly Enforced
    • Figurative Language >
      • Non-Identical Metaphor
      • The Not ... But ... Construct
      • Synecdoche
    • Individual Responsibiity >
      • What is Christianity?
    • Commentaries >
      • Genesis 1-4
      • Gospel of John >
        • John 1-5
        • John 6-10
        • John 11-15
        • John 16-21
      • Acts >
        • Acts 1-5
        • Acts 6-10
        • Acts 11-15
        • Acts 16-20
        • Acts 21-25
        • Acts 26-28
      • Romans >
        • Romans 1-5
        • Romans 6-10
        • Romans 11-16
      • First Corinthians >
        • 1st Corinthians 1-3
        • 1st Corinthians 4-5
        • 1st Corinthians 6-10
        • 1st Corinthians 11-16
      • Second Corinthians >
        • 2nd Corinthians 1-5
        • 2nd Corinthians 6-10
        • 2nd Corinthians 11-13
      • Galatians >
        • Galatians 1-3
        • Galatians 4-6
      • Ephesians >
        • Ephesians 1-3
        • Ephesians 4
        • Ephesians 5-6
      • Philippians
      • First Peter
      • Second Peter
      • Revelation - Supplements >
        • Rev - General Comments
        • Revelation - Overview
        • Rev Beasts and Abyss
        • Rev - Numerology
        • Rev - Rome History Timeline
        • Revelation PPT Slides pdf
        • Rev - Notes Roman Catholic Church
      • Revelation - Commentary >
        • Revelation 1-5
        • Revelation 6-10
        • Revelation 11-15
        • Revelation 16-19
        • Revelation 20-22
  • Introducing Jesus
    • Who is Jesus Article 1 and ToC
    • 2 - A Samaritan Woman Meets Jesus
    • 3 - The Sufferings of Jesus
    • 4 - Was Jesus Who He Claimed to Be?
    • 5 - Why We All Need Jesus
    • 6 - How Well Do You Know Jesus?
    • 7 - Jesus Declares the Father's Name
    • 8 - Jesus, The Master Teacher
    • 9 - What Then Should I Do?
    • 10 - Jesus is God
    • Following Jesus >
      • 1 - I Will Follow (&ToC)
      • 2 - What it Means
      • 3 - Commitment Involved
      • 4 - Following Wherever
      • 5 - To Worship Him
      • 6 - To His Church
  • God's Plan
    • 1. Jesus Commands
    • 2-7. Examples in Acts >
      • 2. Acts 2
      • 3. Acts 8
      • 4. Acts 9
      • 5. Acts 10 and 11
      • 6. Acts 16
      • 7. Acts 19
    • 8. Summary Outline
    • 9. Baptism
    • 10. ??? Thinking ???
    • Saved by God's Righteousness
    • Does Doctrinal Purity Matter? >
      • Not Saved by Faith Only
      • Evidence of Living Faith
      • Not Saved by Works
      • Can a Saved Person be Lost?
      • Faith as the Things Believed
      • Jesus' Intent in John 3:16
      • Back to the Beginning
      • Postscript to Hebrews 11
    • God's Called Out People >
      • Local and Universal Church
      • The Worship of the Lord's Church
      • The Work of the Lord's Church
      • Finding a Church
      • Your Part in the Restoration
      • Creating a New Local Church
    • Hopelessly Lost
  • Pilgrims/Docs/Music
    • Bible Subject Index 1 >
      • Bible Subject Articles 2 >
        • Bible Subject Articles 3 >
          • Family and Home
          • Gambling
          • Giving
          • Happiness
          • Holy Spirit Articles
          • Heaven and Hell
          • Judging and Judgment
          • Love
          • Miracles
          • Profanity
          • Restoration
          • Riches, Materialism
          • Salvation
          • Sexual Immorality
          • Sin
          • Teaching
          • Temptation
          • Textual Studies
          • Unity
          • Where in the Bible?
        • Brief Points
        • Children and Parenting
        • Christian Life
        • Christmas and Holidays
        • Church
        • Church Discipline
        • Church vs Individual Responsibility
        • Clothing-Dating-Dancing
        • Conventional Wisdom
        • Death and Dying
        • Denominationalism
        • Elders and Deacons
        • Evidences and Pride
        • Faith
        • False Doctrines
      • Worship: Lord's Supper
      • Worship: Singing
      • Worship: Prayer
      • Worship: Preaching
      • Worship: Giving
      • Worship: Attendance
      • Abortion
      • Alcohol, Addiction, etc.
      • Attitudes
      • Authority
      • Bible Characters
      • Bible Preservation
      • Biblical Interpretation
      • Blessings
    • Pilgrims in this World >
      • Who is the Real Enemy?
      • Internet Truth Seeking
      • On Judging
      • Demons and Occult >
        • Occult Organizations
        • Bible Teaching on Satan
        • Bible Teaching on Demons
        • Who is Antichrist?
        • Who is Lucifer?
      • Bible and the Koran
      • Are Religious People Happier?
      • Active Shooter Response
      • True Representative Government
      • "No King in Israel"
      • "Give us a King"
      • Eschatology -- End Times
      • The Ultimate Victory
      • Bad Page Link
    • What is Love?
    • Sins of this World >
      • Saving Us from the Practice of Sin
      • The Sin of Deceit
      • Paganism - Bible Answers
      • Ways We Sin
      • Envy and Jealousy
      • Racism/Slavery
      • Economic Immorality
      • Extremism
    • Suffering >
      • Paul Answers Job's Questions
      • Comfort and Refuge
    • Recent Articles
    • Major Documents >
      • Coexisting with Chaos
      • MMLJ -- Old or New Testament?
      • 7 Myths of Denominalationalism >
        • Spanish Version
        • Preface and Table of Contents
        • Myth 1 - Bible is Too Complex to Understand
        • Myth 2 - The Old Testament is Still Binding
        • Myth 3 - We Are Saved by Faith Only
        • Myth 4 - Baptism is of Secondary Importance
        • Myth 5 - All You Need is Love
        • Myth 6 - The Rapture
        • Myth 7 - Original Sin
        • Where Do We Go From Here
    • Contact Us >
      • Distribubion List Form
      • Comment Form
    • Spiritual Songs

The Not ... But ... Construct
by Dave Brown

Go to the Figures of Speech landing page for a more comprehensive review of biblical figures of speech.


INTRODUCTION
​
The “not ... but ...” language construct occurs quite frequently in the bible.  Misunderstanding its meaning has caused many problems of biblical interpretation.  The main problem is that readers tend to take the “not” part of the sentence out of context and make it into an absolute doctrine.  For example, many have concluded from the following that it is a sin for women to wear jewelry (1 Tim. 2:9-10): “Likewise, {I want} women to adorn themselves with proper clothing, modestly and discreetly, not with braided hair and gold or pearls or costly garments; but rather by means of good works, as befits women making a claim to godliness.”  It says it right there: “Not with ...gold or pearls ...”  Is this an absolute prohibition against any jewelry whatsoever?

Before answering this question, let us consider another example.  Jesus said in John 6:27: "Do not work for the food which perishes, but for the food which endures to eternal life, ...”  Is Jesus saying that it is a sin to work and to purchase food with the money earned?  Of course not.  We understand that the “not” part of the expression does not forbid us to work to purchase our food.  Clearly what Jesus said is that eternal life is far, far, far more important than getting a good meal.  It has nothing to do with our secular jobs; there are other passages that give us instruction on that (Tit. 3:14; 1 Tim. 6:17f).

Now, let’s go back to 1 Tim. 2:9 and read it again (in italics above).  See the point?  It is one of emphasis.  Godliness is far, far, far more important than the way that we look.  But does this mean we should not look our best?  Of course not.  Those who interpret this as an edict miss the entire point of what Paul is trying to say.  It is a principle of attitude, not of fashion.  Let us explore this interesting bible language construct in the remainder of this issue.



While many "not ... but ..." constructs do not totally deny the "not ..." clause, we must realize that the majority of the places where these words fall together actually do.  So, it is certainly not in order to make any firm rules about the use of this construct, and while the above should be given consideration, it should not be applied indiscriminately.  Each usage must be evaluated on its own in conjunction with the context, what other simple scriptures say about the subject, and good old common sense (that God has given to all of us and expects us to use).

SOME “NOT ... BUT ...” EXAMPLES

As discussed above, generally the first clause in bible “not ... but ...” expressions are not necessarily absolute.  Rather, this construct is quite often used to greatly emphasize the importance of the second clause over the first.  Let’s consider some examples that have commonly led to errors.  Remember, the principle is an emphasis of the second item over the first, not the absolute statement of the first.

Matt 6:19-20 "Do not lay up for yourselves treasures upon earth, ... But lay up for yourselves treasures in heaven, where neither moth nor rust destroys, ...”

Matt 15:11 "Not what enters into the mouth defiles the man, but what proceeds out of the mouth, this defiles the man."

John 5:30  "I do not seek My own will, but the will of Him who sent Me.”

Rom 2:28-29 “For he is not a Jew who is one outwardly; neither is circumcision that which is outward in the flesh.  But he is a Jew who is one inwardly; and circumcision is that which is of the heart, by the Spirit, not by the letter; and his praise is not from men, but from God.”  (Count them — four in this passage.)

Rom 4:5  “But to the one who does not work, but believes in Him who justifies the ungodly, his faith is reckoned as righteousness, ...”  This one is used as a proof text by people inclined to teach “faith only.”  Obviously it does not; it teaches that trusting (faith) in God is far more important than trusting in our own righteousness (works).

Rom 9:16  “So then it {does} not {depend} on the man who wills or the man who runs, but on God who has mercy.”

Rom 14:13 “Therefore let us not judge one another anymore, but rather determine this-- not to put an obstacle or a stumbling block in a brother's way.”

1 Cor 1:17  “For Christ did not send me to baptize, but to preach the gospel, not in cleverness of speech, that the cross of Christ should not be made void.”

1 Cor 2:4  “And my message and my preaching were not in persuasive words of wisdom, but in demonstration of the Spirit and of power, ...”

1 Tim 1:9  “... realizing the fact that law is not made for a righteous man, but for those who are lawless and rebellious, ...”

We must add that there are some “not... but ...” expressions in the bible where the “not” part is absolute.  The context and a comparison with other scriptures is the key to resolving the true meaning.  It is not difficult if we are willing to dedicate a little time to study the context and the overall subject (2 Tim. 2:15).


What are the conditions of salvation given by Jesus?

Return to the Figures of Speech landing page for a nearly comprehensive review of biblical figures of speech.
Contact Us     Submit a Comment     Register for Weekly Article      Site Guide
Cancer Patients and Caregivers: "No Visitors Please"                                                                       Powered by Weebly
Pledge: this site represents no religious organization; we will not take contributions nor sell anything on this site.