BibleThought
  • Home
    • Hospital Patients/Caregivers >
      • Blessed by an Angel
      • No Visitors Please
      • Side Effects of Chemo
      • Need Help Coping?
      • Cancer and Genetics
    • Site Guide
    • Quora.com Questions
    • 3 Minute Videos
  • Understanding
    • Why I Believe the Bible >
      • Evidence for the Resurrection
      • Arguments Against Evolution
      • Atheism
      • Jesus in History
    • Can We Understand the Bible? >
      • Alleged Contradictions >
        • Is Jesus God?
        • Justified by Works or Not?
        • Predestination or Free Will?
        • Bible Verse Comparisons
      • Difference: Old and New Testaments
      • Bible Complexity
      • Why Are There Difficult Passages?
      • Causes of Common Errors >
        • The Bible's Second Purpose
        • Why Many Will Not Obey?
        • Hasty Generalizations
        • Language of Ashdod
        • Insertion of the "Only" Word
        • Making Rules from Exceptions
    • Is the Bible Sufficient?
    • Translations and Versions
    • Silence of the Scriptures
    • Bible Study Principles >
      • Systematic Bible Study
      • Study the Bible for Yourself
      • The Milk and the Meat
      • Consider the Context
      • Comprehensive Study Techniques
      • Biblical Rules for Study
      • Teaching Aids >
        • Bible Study Questions
        • Teacher's Guide to Questions
        • Periods of Bible History
    • Determining Bible Authority >
      • God's Laws Within Relationships
      • Biblical Commands
      • Biblical Examples
      • Biblical Implications
      • Generic and Specific Commands
      • Example of Conflict Resolution - Acts 15
      • Strictly Enforced
    • Figurative Language >
      • Non-Identical Metaphor
      • The Not ... But ... Construct
      • Synecdoche
    • Individual Responsibiity >
      • What is Christianity?
    • Commentaries >
      • Genesis 1-4
      • Gospel of John >
        • John 1-5
        • John 6-10
        • John 11-15
        • John 16-21
      • Acts >
        • Acts 1-5
        • Acts 6-10
        • Acts 11-15
        • Acts 16-20
        • Acts 21-25
        • Acts 26-28
      • Romans >
        • Romans 1-5
        • Romans 6-10
        • Romans 11-16
      • First Corinthians >
        • 1st Corinthians 1-3
        • 1st Corinthians 4-5
        • 1st Corinthians 6-10
        • 1st Corinthians 11-16
      • Second Corinthians >
        • 2nd Corinthians 1-5
        • 2nd Corinthians 6-10
        • 2nd Corinthians 11-13
      • Galatians >
        • Galatians 1-3
        • Galatians 4-6
      • Ephesians >
        • Ephesians 1-3
        • Ephesians 4
        • Ephesians 5-6
      • Philippians
      • First Peter
      • Second Peter
      • Revelation - Supplements >
        • Rev - General Comments
        • Revelation - Overview
        • Rev Beasts and Abyss
        • Rev - Numerology
        • Rev - Rome History Timeline
        • Revelation PPT Slides pdf
        • Rev - Notes Roman Catholic Church
      • Revelation - Commentary >
        • Revelation 1-5
        • Revelation 6-10
        • Revelation 11-15
        • Revelation 16-19
        • Revelation 20-22
  • Introducing Jesus
    • Who is Jesus Article 1 and ToC
    • 2 - A Samaritan Woman Meets Jesus
    • 3 - The Sufferings of Jesus
    • 4 - Was Jesus Who He Claimed to Be?
    • 5 - Why We All Need Jesus
    • 6 - How Well Do You Know Jesus?
    • 7 - Jesus Declares the Father's Name
    • 8 - Jesus, The Master Teacher
    • 9 - What Then Should I Do?
    • 10 - Jesus is God
    • Following Jesus >
      • 1 - I Will Follow (&ToC)
      • 2 - What it Means
      • 3 - Commitment Involved
      • 4 - Following Wherever
      • 5 - To Worship Him
      • 6 - To His Church
  • God's Plan
    • 1. Jesus Commands
    • 2-7. Examples in Acts >
      • 2. Acts 2
      • 3. Acts 8
      • 4. Acts 9
      • 5. Acts 10 and 11
      • 6. Acts 16
      • 7. Acts 19
    • 8. Summary Outline
    • 9. Baptism
    • 10. ??? Thinking ???
    • Saved by God's Righteousness
    • Does Doctrinal Purity Matter? >
      • Not Saved by Faith Only
      • Evidence of Living Faith
      • Not Saved by Works
      • Can a Saved Person be Lost?
      • Faith as the Things Believed
      • Jesus' Intent in John 3:16
      • Back to the Beginning
      • Postscript to Hebrews 11
    • God's Called Out People >
      • Local and Universal Church
      • The Worship of the Lord's Church
      • The Work of the Lord's Church
      • Finding a Church
      • Your Part in the Restoration
      • Creating a New Local Church
    • Hopelessly Lost
  • Pilgrims/Docs/Music
    • Bible Subject Index 1 >
      • Bible Subject Articles 2 >
        • Bible Subject Articles 3 >
          • Family and Home
          • Gambling
          • Giving
          • Happiness
          • Holy Spirit Articles
          • Heaven and Hell
          • Judging and Judgment
          • Love
          • Miracles
          • Profanity
          • Restoration
          • Riches, Materialism
          • Salvation
          • Sexual Immorality
          • Sin
          • Teaching
          • Temptation
          • Textual Studies
          • Unity
          • Where in the Bible?
        • Brief Points
        • Children and Parenting
        • Christian Life
        • Christmas and Holidays
        • Church
        • Church Discipline
        • Church vs Individual Responsibility
        • Clothing-Dating-Dancing
        • Conventional Wisdom
        • Death and Dying
        • Denominationalism
        • Elders and Deacons
        • Evidences and Pride
        • Faith
        • False Doctrines
      • Worship: Lord's Supper
      • Worship: Singing
      • Worship: Prayer
      • Worship: Preaching
      • Worship: Giving
      • Worship: Attendance
      • Abortion
      • Alcohol, Addiction, etc.
      • Attitudes
      • Authority
      • Bible Characters
      • Bible Preservation
      • Biblical Interpretation
      • Blessings
    • Pilgrims in this World >
      • Who is the Real Enemy?
      • Internet Truth Seeking
      • On Judging
      • Demons and Occult >
        • Occult Organizations
        • Bible Teaching on Satan
        • Bible Teaching on Demons
        • Who is Antichrist?
        • Who is Lucifer?
      • Bible and the Koran
      • Are Religious People Happier?
      • Active Shooter Response
      • True Representative Government
      • "No King in Israel"
      • "Give us a King"
      • Eschatology -- End Times
      • The Ultimate Victory
      • Bad Page Link
    • What is Love?
    • Sins of this World >
      • Saving Us from the Practice of Sin
      • The Sin of Deceit
      • Paganism - Bible Answers
      • Ways We Sin
      • Envy and Jealousy
      • Racism/Slavery
      • Economic Immorality
      • Extremism
    • Suffering >
      • Paul Answers Job's Questions
      • Comfort and Refuge
    • Recent Articles
    • Major Documents >
      • Coexisting with Chaos
      • MMLJ -- Old or New Testament?
      • 7 Myths of Denominalationalism >
        • Spanish Version
        • Preface and Table of Contents
        • Myth 1 - Bible is Too Complex to Understand
        • Myth 2 - The Old Testament is Still Binding
        • Myth 3 - We Are Saved by Faith Only
        • Myth 4 - Baptism is of Secondary Importance
        • Myth 5 - All You Need is Love
        • Myth 6 - The Rapture
        • Myth 7 - Original Sin
        • Where Do We Go From Here
    • Contact Us >
      • Distribubion List Form
      • Comment Form
    • Spiritual Songs

Music in Worship
     Can we Sing and Play? by Bryan Gibson
     Why Don't You Use Instruments of Music? Author Unknown

 

Return to Bible Subjects Articles page
 




Can We Sing and Play?
by Bryan Gibson

“Let the word of Christ dwell in you richly in all wisdom, teaching and admonishing one another in psalms and hymns and spiritual songs, singing with grace in your hearts to the Lord” (Colossians 3:16).

The above passage gives a command: sing with grace in our hearts to the Lord. And we are told what to sing: psalms, hymns, and spiritual songs. But consider this question: When we sing these psalms, hymns, and spiritual songs to the Lord, can we use an instrument of music to accompany us, like a piano, organ, guitar, etc.? Would it be pleasing to God for us to play on these instruments while singing these songs?

First, we need to figure out where to go to find the answer to this question. Obviously, to find out whether or not something is pleasing to God, we need to look in God’s word—the Bible. From reading passages like Psalms 150 and 2 Chronicles 29:25, it would appear that God does want us to play as well as sing. But not so fast. The problem with these two passages is that they are in the Old Testament and have to do with Old Testament worship. Are we prepared to restore Old Testament worship, with the daily animal sacrifices, the burning of incense, the separate priesthood, etc.? Of course, the reason we can’t restore any of this is that the Old Law, or the Law of Moses, has been taken out of the way. While we can certainly benefit from the many lessons taught in it, it is no longer a source of authority for us today. Please read Galatians 3:23-25; Ephesians 2:14-16; Colossians 2:13-14, 16-17; Hebrews 9:16-17. So to find out whether or not we can use instruments in our worship today, we must look to the New Testament.

When we look through the New Testament, we do find at least four different instruments mentioned: the trumpet, the flute, the harp, and the cymbal (see 1 Corinthians 13:1; 14:7-9, 15; 15:51-52; Revelation 8:2, 6, 13; 9:14; and others). But here’s what else we find. There is nothing said in any of these passages about the use of these instruments in the worship we are to offer to God. We are not asking whether or not it is right to ever play these instruments. We are concerned with whether or not we can use them in worship to God, whether or not we can use them when we sing psalms, hymns, and spiritual songs to the Lord.

When we look at the passages in the New Testament that have something to say about the worship we are to offer to God today, specifically the music we offer in worship, we find no mention of an instrument. Read the following passages for yourself: Acts 16:25; Romans 15:8-9; 1 Corinthians 14:15; Ephesians 5:19; Colossians 3:16; Hebrews 2:11-12; Hebrews 13:15; James 5:13. We’ve already seen that instruments are mentioned throughout the New Testament, so they were readily available. But in the passages that have to do with what we are to offer to God, we are simply taught to sing. To use an instrument, we would have to go beyond God’s word, or add to it, and we cannot do that (2 John 1:9; Revelation 22:18-19). Jesus said, “Follow Me,” not, “Run ahead of Me.”



“Why Don’t You Use Instrumental Music?”
Author Unknown

Frequently we are asked about our practice of observing a cappella music in our worship services. Folks are curious. They want to know why we don’t have instrumental music. Our practice is different—we’re not like the majority of other religious groups. What is the reason? People really want to know. So they ask, “Why don’t you use instrumental music?”

With no intention to be flippant, we might very well respond with a counter-question: “Why should we?” That’s fair, isn’t it? Those who think that instrumental music is right and proper ought to be able to tell us why they think so. When we ask this question, the typical responses are:
“We really like instrumental music.” Be careful here—remember that our goal is to please God, not men, not even ourselves (Gal.1:10).

“Well, everyone else is doing it.” Anyone who thinks that this proves the acceptability of a thing needs to be reminded that Jesus said the majority of people (even the majority of “religious” people) will be condemned in the day of judgment. Read Matthew 7:13-14, 21-23.

“God gave certain people musical talent, and they ought to be able to use it.” If this logic works, then the fella who is a talented auto mechanic would be justified in rebuilding a car engine during the worship services, too. And the surgeon who wants to glorify God could do an appendectomy before the assembled congregation. Surely we can see the flawed thinking behind this argument.

“They used instruments in the Old Testament.” True, but we are no longer under that law (Col. 2:14-16). We need to find our authority in the New Testament—and there is none.

In the final analysis, everything we do religiously must be based on the authority of the Lord (Col. 3:17). If we cannot defend a practice by appealing to the Scriptures, then we ought not to do it. There is simply no New Testament authority for the use of instrumental music in our worship. That should settle it!

 

What are the conditions of salvation given by Jesus?

Return to Bible Subjects Articles page




Contact Us     Submit a Comment     Register for Weekly Article      Site Guide
Cancer Patients and Caregivers: "No Visitors Please"                                                                       Powered by Weebly
Pledge: this site represents no religious organization; we will not take contributions nor sell anything on this site.